Vaping vs. Cigarettes: Insights Gained from Two Weeks of Research
Written on
Vaping has emerged as a potential alternative for many smokers, including myself. After a decade of smoking, I recently quit, motivated by a desire to improve my health. Despite enjoying smoking, I found it increasingly frustrating to maintain my health goals while still indulging in cigarettes. Vaping seemed like a possible escape.
However, I had numerous questions, and reliable information was difficult to find. To address my curiosity—and for the sake of my father, who has smoked his whole life, and my friends—I decided to compile my findings in this article. This piece, featuring around 50 references for further exploration, is lengthy, so feel free to save it for later or jump to the key findings.
For smokers, I hope this encourages you to reconsider your choices. For those who know smokers, I urge you to share this information.
Why is Vaping Appealing?
Vaping differs significantly from smoking. While a cigarette provides a singular experience—smoke it or don’t—vaping offers a customizable experience that intertwines various scientific disciplines like chemistry and toxicology.
With vaping, you can adjust numerous elements: the size of the vapor clouds, the intensity of the throat hit, airflow, temperature, flavor, and even the design of the device. This vast array of choices allows for a personalized experience that can make vaping more enjoyable than smoking.
But the question remains: is it a suitable choice?
Understanding Vaping in Simple Terms
A vaping device generates vapor by heating a wire coil wrapped in cotton that is soaked in e-liquid, powered by a battery.
What Comprises Vape Juice?
Vape juice is made up of four main ingredients: 1. Propylene Glycol (PG) 2. Vegetable Glycerin (VG) 3. Flavorings 4. Nicotine (optional)
Conversely, traditional cigarettes contain around 19 ingredients, including nicotine, tar, and ammonia, among others. In 1994, tobacco companies were legally required to disclose additives, revealing a staggering 599 substances.
Cigarette smoke is particularly complex, containing over 5,000 chemicals, including 60 recognized carcinogens. In contrast, a 2021 study showed that vaping produced approximately 2,000 largely unidentified chemicals, with some potentially harmful.
While 'unidentified' doesn't equate to 'safe,' it’s evident that the combustion process in cigarettes results in a more complex and hazardous smoke.
My approach is to compare the most prevalent harmful substances in both vaping and smoking.
“The Dose Makes The Poison” — Paracelsus ca. 1540
This principle has been pivotal in my research. Understanding that almost everything has a dose-dependent relationship is crucial—too much of anything can be harmful.
Let’s delve deeper:
Nicotine — Misunderstood Substance
Nicotine is often mistakenly vilified due to its association with smoking. Despite being addictive, studies from the UK’s National Health Service indicate that nicotine may have relatively minor health risks. Interestingly, it has been linked to a reduced likelihood of developing Parkinson’s disease, showcasing its potential benefits.
Formaldehyde (Methanal)
This colorless gas is known to be potentially carcinogenic. It’s produced through various metabolic processes and is prevalent in cigarettes. Dosage is key, as exposure limits exist.
Acetaldehyde (Ethanal)
Primarily associated with alcohol metabolism, this compound is also found in tobacco products. It exhibits carcinogenic properties and its exposure levels vary between cigarettes and e-liquids.
Acrolein
Known for its irritating properties, it is linked to severe respiratory issues in excessive amounts. Again, dosage is crucial in evaluating risk.
Diacetyl (Flavoring)
This compound, known for its buttery flavor, has been linked to respiratory diseases. It was banned in the EU and UK due to its association with "Popcorn Lung," although studies show a significant disparity in exposure levels between vaping and smoking.
Heavy Metals
Research on heavy metals in vaping is murky. Some studies indicate low levels of exposure compared to conventional smoking, but the findings are varied.
Fluid Buildup in the Lungs (Pneumonia)
Contrary to misconceptions, pneumonia is primarily caused by specific pathogens, not water vapor. A 2021 study found that all tested e-liquids exhibited antibacterial properties, suggesting a potential protective effect.
Knowledge Gaps
Vaping is still a relatively new field, and while there are many unknowns, recent studies indicate that it can aid smoking cessation.
Vaping is Safer
The goal of harm reduction is paramount. My journey through this research has highlighted the extreme dangers associated with traditional cigarettes. Despite the risks associated with vaping, it is undoubtedly a safer alternative.
Ultimately, the aim should be to phase out both smoking and vaping through effective nicotine control. Gradually reducing nicotine levels can facilitate a transition to a nicotine-free lifestyle.
Final Thoughts
If you're transitioning from smoking to vaping, prioritize quality and simplicity. Choose reputable products, monitor your nicotine intake, and aim for a smoother experience.
Remember: Vaping is not without risks, and this article advocates for harm reduction rather than encouraging vaping among non-smokers.